The Aquilaria Tree Scheme
I read Straits Times today and saw this news:Link: http://www.straitstimes.com/business/investors-cry-foul-over-tree-investments-gone-wrong
The "deal" in summary:
Pay $230 per sapling or $550 per semi-mature tree
Tenure: 6-7 years when tree matures
Returns: 6-7 times when Agarwood is harvested from each tree
What does this mean: 100% returns averaged out in 1 yr.
In 2013, my friend proudly told me her investment in this Aquilaria Tree. She said that she bought a few trees and when these trees matures, it produces Agarwood which can be sold. She can sell at $400-$600 for each tola of Agarwood oil harvested.
I told her then that this was very likely a scam. How can there be such a good deal? $400 return after 6 yrs when the investment is only $500?
SURE ANOT? 100% return?
She told me that she was very sure. The investors even told her they could bring her to see the actual trees planted. Furthermore, it was a Singapore based company.
Hai.. so now this Singapore company has folded and gone MIA. Hard earned money of my friend all gone..
Previously, I have written a post about Pre-IPO Scams, link here.
How to identify potential investment scams:
1. It promises high returns with a very low risk.
What is high return?
Returns through various investments:
0.025% savings account
1.3% 1-year FD
3.25% OCBC 360 Account
7.8% S&P 500
15% Warren Buffet
Warren Buffet, one of the richest person on Earth, returns from the stock market is about 15%. Do you honestly think that you can get an investment that yields a higher return than Buffet consistently and at a low risk?
2. You are enticed through telemarketing
A good investment will be secretly kept in wraps and for traders/big investors to earn. Heck, if I can earn via arbitrage or if I know a very good investment, I will keep it a secret and profit hugely myself.
If a good investment has to be promoted through telemarketing, it is just desperate.
Lastly, some lessons to learn:
1. 'Alternative Investments' such as venture capital, private equity, hedge funds, real estate investment trusts, commodities as,precious metals, rare coins, wine, and art are normally directly sold to people with high net worth. You may a private banker from a known bank helping you to invest in such things.
Such a creative idea... Aquilaria Tree and agarwood lol.
2. Read more and understand better before investing. You should be sure of what you are buying, please read more and please read from expert reports. If you do not know anything, at least GOOGLE.
3. If you cannot resist the temptation to make money quickly and easily, you are bound to lose money. I have written a post here . There is no easy and quick money in the world la alamak. Warren buffet reads 8 hours a day and is innately talented, and his returns are 15%.
Ok, that's all from me in this matter. :)
Hi there,
ReplyDeleteI think that people who fall for these scams do not have the proper financial knowledge OR they are just blinded by the promised easy gains. A truly financially smart person will know the tradeoffs between risk and return.
I pity the elderly people who got cheated by their hard earned money due to them being too trusting and less savvy in investments :(
Hi Heidi,
ReplyDeleteI'm glad you covered this piece of news as I was just reading about it the other day. It's frustrating how scams like that continue to exist in Singapore and people just get cheated out of their money by not being careful.
Cheers,
TFS
Hi TFS,
DeleteThank you your comment! Let's just hope that investors are more cautious and not fall prey to such scams anymore.